01 / The name
Pleading the fifth
The name comes from a piece of pastry. Rythm Gupta was at a friend's place, he says, when he took the last piece while no one was in the room. Everyone wanted to know where it had gone. He was watching Suits at the time, the series with Harvey Specter, and remembered an episode where they plead the fifth: the American right to remain silent rather than incriminate yourself. He stayed silent.
“That's where the name clicked from,” he told Brisbane Food Guide in his home kitchen on 27 September 2026. “Whenever you get asked about the last piece, just plead the fifth.”
The Fifth Amendment is the result: cookies and cakes baked at home and ordered through Instagram.

02 / Why baking
The oven, not the stove
Baking runs in the family. Rythm says his mother has been a baker for about 15 years. She bakes and designs cakes, sells them and teaches children.
His own way in was cooking. When he got into fitness, he says, he had to cook all his meals himself, and as the only non-vegetarian in a vegetarian family, the meat dishes were his job. That made him fall in love with cooking.
Restaurant kitchens were another matter. “Hot kitchens are very tense,” he says. He had seen professional kitchens and watched his mother work. “I can't deal with that hot kitchen tense.” So he asked himself what was more fun and more appealing to the eye, and the answer was baking.
His first memory of cooking with her is older. About ten years ago, at 14, he asked her to teach him a round roti. The first one, he says, came out looking like a map of India. “I make pretty good roti now.”

03 / What he bakes
Crunchy outside, melted inside
If someone orders one thing, Rythm says it should be his centre-filled cookies: crunchy outside, gooey and melted inside. His suggestion is to warm one a little, add vanilla ice cream and drink it with a black coffee.
On the day BFG visited, there was a red velvet cookie with white chocolate chips, one of his favourites, and a marble cake. The cake is one of the things he learned from his mother, a chocolate and vanilla sponge that shows its swirl only when it is cut. He usually pairs it with chocolate ganache.
He also wants to make a cookie tin, which he says is popular in the UK and India: a cookie shell with melted chocolate ganache in the middle, scooped out like a dessert.

04 / Sugar-free
Baking for a family with diabetes
Asked what would make his bakery different, Rythm pointed to his family. Diabetes runs in it, he says, and he wondered what could make people happy who love sweets but cannot eat them.
His answer is that most of his cookies can be made sugar-free, using fruit sweeteners instead of sugar, and that he can also make gluten-free and lactose-free versions. These are his own descriptions of what he can make on request. Anyone ordering for a health or dietary reason should check the ingredients with him directly.

05 / The plan
Pop-ups first, a flagship later
When we spoke, The Fifth Amendment was very new. “I started last week,” Rythm said, “so three or four orders already delivered.”
His plans run well ahead of that. He wants to start pop-up stores around Brisbane next year and, “if everything goes right”, to open a flagship store in the city within two years. He imagines it serving drinks from beyond the usual coffee list, such as Kashmiri kahwa, a saffron tea, and kokum sherbet. “It's not going to be another cafe,” he says. “It's going to be an artisan bakery.”
For now, it is one person baking at home, with a mother who has done it for 15 years to learn from, and a name that started with the last piece of pastry on someone else's table.
The business
The Fifth Amendment
The Fifth Amendment is a home bakery taking orders through Instagram (@the.fifth.amendment). The account was private when we checked on 20 November 2026, and trading details may have changed since the September interview. Contact the business directly before ordering, especially for sugar-free, gluten-free or lactose-free requests.
Find The Fifth Amendment on InstagramShare this story
Pass it on.
Send this founder story to a friend, save the link, or share it from the venue.
More founder stories
- Fatty Patty was meant to be simple. The brothers had other ideas.
A steak sandwich they had to rethink, a smoker they debated buying, and three brothers whose different strengths keep bringing them back to the same table.
- Ben Williamson on learning to let go
The Anyday co-founder on delegating earlier, giving his chefs room to contribute and losing the need to prove himself on every plate.
- The Shake Up: preparing before the turnout is known
Atiana wants steadier work for the burger truck she had long wanted to run. At Logan Eats, she explains the preparation behind an uncertain turnout, and the returning customers who make the business feel personal.
